Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Title: Why We Fight

Author: Dee

Chapter: 2/3
Rating: NC-17 or MA

Characters: Dean/OFC/Sam

Disclaimer: I don’t own my navel lint. This is for entertainment purposes only. No copyright infringement intended.

Summary: The brothers add a third hunter to their two-man team against the supernatural. They find that the perks extend further than the fight.
Author’s Note: These events take place after AHBL II but Sam survived his wound from Jake and Dean didn’t make the deal with the Crossroads Demon.


Dean stopped the movement of his finger and Sam separated his mouth from her blood-engorged peak to look down into her face. Her eyes were still clenched tight, her chest still heaved for control of her breath, and she was coiled tight enough to spring off the bed at any given second. The brothers hesitantly looked at each other hoping the other would come up with something to say to her but they had nothing.


“I had 5 older cousins that chased the boys off when I was younger and by the time I took to hunting, I just never found the time or the right person,” Alex broke the silence and flushed in humiliation making her dark-tanned skin a deep crimson before she opened her eyes still avoiding their gaze. “It crossed my mind more times than I can count but I never wanted to deal with falling for someone and having to explain why I had to bail or picking up a one-night stand and making a mistake that cost me my life just because I’m horny,” she let out a small laugh along with a few tears. “I’ve got to give you two credit. I tell you I’m a virgin and you haven’t run from me or burst into laughter.”


“We wouldn’t do that, baby,” Sam whispered in her ear before he kissed her temple and flicked his thumb over her nipple to watch her eyes droop and her head roll on the pillow.


“Why us, sweetheart?” Dean asked from her side and stared into her eyes when she gazed at him.


“A number of reasons,” she whispered as she raised her hand to palm his cheek. “You’re both sin on two legs for one,” she laughed softly when Dean smirked and Sam chuckled against her shoulder. “A girl would have to be dead and in our business, crossed over to not notice how hot you are but that aside, we have everything in common,” the smile faded and her eyes focused beyond him. “We have almost every detail of our lives in common except you had each other. I’ve been alone for so long the only thing that keeps me sane is meditation and training. You both know the job,” she glanced back at Dean as she lifted her other hand to rest on Sam’s. “You know what we face, what we have to do, and the importance of doing it. We can walk away from each other afterwards and not have to explain.”


“Any particular reason why you want both of us instead of picking one?” Dean lifted one eyebrow waiting for an explanation. “A virgin usually doesn’t pick her first time to be a threesome, babe.”


“I could never choose between you,” she looked back and forth between them. “Both of you call to a particular side of me. If I can’t have both of you I don’t want either of you,” she whispered as she lowered her eyes.


Silence fell over the room like a thick fog. Dean glanced up at his brother trying to get a read on what he was thinking before he gently slipped his finger free of her body and rested his hand on her abdomen. “Lex, why don’t you go into the bathroom and get out of those clothes? Give Sam and I a minute to talk,” he smiled and gently rubbed her stomach when she looked at him hesitantly. “No matter what we decide, we’ll be here for you when you come out,” he held her chin forcing her to look in his eyes. “Okay?”


“Okay,” she whispered before she moved to the end of the bed and walked into the bathroom closing the door behind her.


“You up for this, Sammy?” Dean sat up against the headboard and stared at the opposite wall. “You heard her, it’s a packaged deal. We were forced to share a lot of things in our life but never a woman.”


“I want her, Dean,” Sam turned to look at his brother, his heart shining in his eyes. “We do have everything in common. I’ve never met anyone like her except for us,” Sam shook his head with a furrowed brow. “That sounded weird but you know what I mean. She’s like you and me in one person. Crap! That sounded even worse,” Sam draped an arm over his eyes in frustration.


“It’s okay, Sammy,” Dean laughed as he swatted his brother in the chest. “I know what you mean. So the question now is,” Dean waited until Sam looked at him before he continued. “Which one of us gets the honor of being her first?”


“I’ve never been any girl’s first,” Sam closed his eyes and shook his head. “I can’t believe we’re having this discussion.”


“Do you think this is easy for me? I get a raging hard on every time I see her and now I’ve gotta watch you take her virginity,” he shrugged his shoulders when Sam looked at him with his mouth gaping open. “You should be the one,” Dean said softly before he pointed a hard finger at him. “But go easy on her. We don’t want to scare her the first time out of the gate.”


“Okay,” Sam nodded his head as he swallowed heavily.


“Strip down to your boxers and get under the covers,” Dean said as he stood beside the bed pulling off his shirt and working on his jeans. “I don’t even want to see your ass so stay under the blankets until the lights are off.”




Ten minutes later, Alex opened the bathroom door with a shaking hand cursing herself for acting like…well a virgin. She had stripped naked but wrapped a towel around her body within seconds of entering the bathroom. If they decided not to do this, she didn’t want to be any more naked physically than she already felt emotionally.


One light was on by the bathroom door so it took a moment for her eyes to adjust to the darkness in the bedroom. A few more steps into the room and she smiled shyly when she found Sam and Dean reclining against the headboard of her bed, their chests bare and the covers up to their waists. She worried her bottom lip between her teeth when she stood at the foot of the bed and caught their hungry gazes running over her form.


“Suddenly I feel foolish,” she whispered as she wrapped her arms around herself.


“Just say the word and we can just sleep like we did before,” Dean sat forward, staring into her worried eyes. “We won’t push you into anything here, Lex.”


“Okay,” she released a deep breath before she climbed up the center of the bed, slid under the covers and settled between them. “I feel like a teenager,” she laughed humorlessly. “I should’ve done this years ago or not at all. I don’t think I’ll survive my embarrassment.”


“I think its special that you didn’t do it just for the sake of doing it,” Sam rolled on to his side, propping his head up on his hand to look down at her. “You had genuine reasons for not having sex before. One-night stands weren’t your thing and you didn’t want the pain of hurting yourself or someone else if you cared about them. Our line of work isn’t conducive to relationships, Lex.”


“It sounded feasible in my head for years and even when I told you but now,” she trailed off, avoiding his eyes.


“Don’t doubt your decision then or now,” Sam smiled as he cupped her cheek in his large palm and kissed her softly on her trembling lips.


Alex began to relax as he explored the recesses of her mouth. His gentleness and care made the things she was feeling earlier resurface and stoke a fire in her veins.


He parted from her lips reluctantly but wanted to look into her eyes when he did this. His hands gently eased the material of the towel apart to expose her to them. Sam’s breath caught in his throat at the sheer beauty of this woman. He ran his hand almost reverently down her throat, the valley between her breasts, over her abdomen, and cupped her feminine heat.


“You’re the most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen,” Sam whispered against her lips before he slid one long finger into her pussy. “I just need to get you ready for us, baby,” he kissed her quickly before he scooted down the bed to lie on his stomach between her spread legs.


“Relax, Alex,” Dean rolled over and slid his hand into her hair pulling her into a deep kiss. “If Sam is any good at this, you’re gonna love it,” he grinned when her eyes rolled back in her head and she arched off the bed. “I guess you have a talent after all, Sammy,” Dean glanced down at his brother whose face was buried between Alex’s legs. He was lapping at the length of her dripping folds before he latched on to her clit. Dean turned back to her, feeling himself harden from her moans and whimpers and lowered his head down to capture a nipple between his teeth.


The sensations that coursed through Alex were foreign to her but intensely pleasurable. The electric shocks that shot through her body from every touch of Sam’s tongue to her clit made her feel like she was floating yet every bite from Dean’s teeth on her sensitive nipples anchored her to the world.


Sam added a second finger after he feasted on her essence for a few minutes. Despite the fact that he was on cloud nine, he still had the insight to prepare her body for his occupation. She was soaking his fingers with her arousal but she was incredibly tight around two of his fingers so he added a third and stretched her as much as possible.


A glance up her body showed Dean sucking voraciously on one tit while his hand squeezed the other in almost a milking motion engorging the nipple. Sam felt Alex begin to convulse around his fingers with her oncoming orgasm. Her loud cries and writhing body told Dean she was close. He quickly switched nipples and bit down hard on the blood-filled tip while Sam flicked her clit repeatedly until she screamed out with her climax.


Sam withdrew his fingers and continued to lap at her drenched folds while he used his free hand to push down his boxers. He crawled up her body after Dean kissed her gently and moved aside. “You okay, baby?” he asked her softly. He smiled when she nodded her head still gasping for breath. He fisted his hard length and rubbed the head over her cum-soaked lips watching her eyes widen as he did so. “I won’t lie to you, this is gonna hurt for a bit but we’ll take it slow until you say it’s okay to go on, okay?”


“Okay,” she whispered with a jerk of her head.


“Wrap your legs around his waist, Lex,” Dean said in a soothing tone from her side. “It’ll help open you up for him,” he smiled down at her when she looked at him and did as he said. “Good girl,” he ran his hand over her hair and watched her tense up. He assumed Sam had just gotten the head in but refused to look so he continued to pet her hair and face. “Just relax, babe.”


Alex clenched her eyes tight when she felt Sam slowly move inch by excruciating inch of his obviously long and thick shaft into her tight passage. He waited a few moments before he made each tiny moment forward to allow her to get accustomed to his size. He felt resistance within her and knew he reached her hymen. This was going to be the hard part and he almost regretted it since he could see she was already in discomfort. “Baby, this next part is gonna hurt but I promise it will pass, okay?” he felt his heart clinch in his chest when she looked at him with fear-filled eyes and nodded her head before he pushed forward and broke the thin barrier.


“Shh,” Dean whispered in her ear still running his hand over her hair when she bit her bottom lip and tears leaked from her clenched eyes. “It’s okay, sweetheart. The hard part is over.” He glanced at his brother’s tense face and straining shoulders and knew Sam was buried to the hilt within her tight pussy and fighting the urge to move. “Sammy, you stay still for a moment, okay?” His brother nodded his head in small jerking motions and Dean shook his head in wonder. ‘I can’t believe I am coaching my brother on how to take a girl’s virginity.’


After several minutes, Alex released her lip from her teeth and gasped heavily through her mouth as she clutched on to Sam’s shoulders. “Now,” she whispered and stared into his eyes when they snapped open.


He was going to ask if she was sure but he could see it in her eyes. He slowly pulled back and pushed forward in tiny movements for her to get used to it. It didn’t take long before the hands that held on to his shoulders in pain and panic were soon running over his flesh like a lover’s would.


They never broke eye contact while he stroked in and out of her in long, lazy movements. They didn’t even close their eyes when they kissed so deeply that they breathed through each other. Sam was making love to her. Dean knew he was the better choice for taking her virginity for this very reason. It had been a long time since Dean made love to any woman and he didn’t want to hurt this one.


He thought he would be grossed out to watch this but his eyes were riveted to the couple. This was love in its most beautiful form. Two people, who couldn’t tear their eyes off of each other, shared the same oxygen when they kissed, and held on to each other’s shoulders as they rode towards completion of the act. The beauty of it stunned Dean.


Sam labored for breath and the ability to control himself. He didn’t want to lose it and cum without her but she was so tight that he could barely breathe from the pressure of her body on his shaft. They were both slick with sweat and gasping through their mouths when he sped up his thrusts. He moaned and she cried out with every slap of their pelvises.


“Sam!” Alex cried out and dug her fingers into his shoulders when she felt that tingling sensation spread through her.


“Cum for me, baby,” he gasped before his eyes finally screwed shut when she clenched him within her. “Alex!” Sam cried out as he jerked his release into her welcoming depths while she convulsed with hers. Their orgasms seemed to go on forever as they clutched on to each other until Sam finally collapsed on top of her. “Are you okay?” he rose back up on his forearms and looked down at her in concern.


“I’m more than okay,” she smiled with a blush.


“Am I squashing you?”


“I can bench press your weight,” she laughed softly before she dug her fingers into his shaggy hair and pulled him into a kiss. “Thank you,” she whispered against his lips.


“For what?”


“Making this as special and loving as you did,” she kissed him once again before she turned her head to the side. “Dean?” she called out when she didn’t see him in the room.


“I’m running you a shower, sweetheart,” he said as he walked back in. “Get off her already, Sam,” he averted his eyes while his brother pulled out of her body and flopped over on his back before he bent down, picked her up and carried her towards the bathroom. “My turn,” he smiled when he stepped into the stall and moved them under the spray.


“That feels heavenly,” Alex moaned as the warm water ran over her hair and flesh. “Why’s the tub filled and what are the candles for?” she asked him with a smile as she pushed her drenched hair out of her eyes.


“We’re just getting you cleaned up in here,” he set her down on her feet and grabbed her puff. “We’ll be moving in there in a moment,” he grinned as he poured some of her body wash on it, lathered it up and ran it over her body. “Am I doing this right?” he asked as he moved it down her abdomen and smirked when she moaned. “I guess so.” He soaped up her entire body except for one spot. He knelt before her as she leaned heavily against the wall. “Babe, this might be a little uncomfortable. Let me know if you want to do it, okay?”


“Okay,” she moaned before her eyes flew open when he moved the puff gently between her legs.


“Is that okay?” he asked with a hint of concern in his eyes but smiled when she nodded her head. He washed her body thoroughly before he moved her under the spray to rinse off. The second the last of the suds left her skin, he picked her up and carried her into the tub. “Sam, the shower is free!” he yelled out as they sank into the warm water.


When Sam walked into the bathroom, they were kneeling in the tub facing each other. Dean held her face gently between his hands and kissed her until her breathing was shot. Sam moved into the shower and watched them through the opaque glass while he cleaned up.


Dean’s hand brushed her hair off of one shoulder while his tongue occupied her mouth before he broke the kiss and trailed his lips over the side of her neck, nibbling down to her shoulder. His attention moved to her breasts when her hardened nipples dragged across his chest with each breath she took.


He wrapped an arm around her back, pulling her towards him while his free hand pushed her shoulders back to offer her breasts to his waiting mouth. He dipped his head down drawing one tip into the warmth of his mouth and laved it with his tongue. He pulled back and blew across the saliva-coated nipple and smiled when she moaned, as it grew even tighter.


He repeated the same torture to the other nipple while he grabbed her free breast in one hand and slid the other down between her legs. He rubbed her clit in a circular motion and groaned when she bucked her hips. ‘Our girl isn’t as inhibited anymore,’ he thought to himself when she ground her pussy against his palm. “Come here, baby,” he whispered in a desire thick voice when he felt her arousal on his hand.


Dean moved behind her and carefully pushed her forward. “Grab the edge of the tub, sweetheart,” he directed her until she was bent over in front of him with her delicious ass rubbing against his hard length. He fisted his cock, positioning himself at her entrance and sank into her tight depths. “You’re so tight,” he hissed as his head went back in ecstasy. “So damn hot,” his hands slid up her sides to cup her breasts and pulled her back into his thrusting hips.


Sam watched them through the glass. Alex’s eyes were screwed shut. Dean’s biceps flexed every time he pulled her back into his penetration. He watched as Alex rose up resting her head against Dean’s chest even as her hands came up to grab his shoulders. He watched as Dean bit the joint of her neck and shoulder, squeezing her breasts together before his fingers pulled at her nipples.


He didn’t think he could stomach watching his brother take Alex but this erotic dance of primal mating was beautiful to behold. The sound of Dean’s grunts and groans and Alex’s whimpers and moans were a symphony of lovemaking. Alex began to cry out when Dean increased his tempo, his hips slapping against her ass.


Dean wrapped his arms across her chest and pulled her down on to his invading shaft until she threw her head back and cried out his name and he buried his face in her neck and jerked his release into her. He watched Dean slip from her body; he could see his brother missed the feel of her already just like he did when he withdrew from her. He watched him lay back and pull her down between his legs to recline in the cooling water. Sam was in awe of the act. He played her body like a fine instrument and she was responsive to everything he did.


After Dean got control of his breathing, he grabbed a washcloth, dipped it in the bubbles and gently washed between her legs while she lay boneless against him. “You okay, babe?” he whispered against her ear and she lazily nodded her head. “I think you’ve had enough for tonight,” he chuckled before he kissed the side of her head.


“I think we’re going to have to dry her off and get her to bed judging by how wiped she is,” Sam said as he wrapped a towel around his lean hips before he moved to take her limp body from his brother. “Cover yourself up and help me out with her,” Sam spoke over his shoulder as he placed her on the vanity and held her up with one arm while he dried her upper body with the other.


“You were right,” Dean whispered when he joined him and ran a towel over her lower body. “She’s the most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen too,” he exchanged a smile with his brother before Sam carried her out to the bedroom. “I laid a blanket down on the sheet that was…you know,” he said shyly before he placed her in the center.


“Good thinking since it wouldn’t be cool to call Housekeeping and ask them to change the sheets while we were doing our thing in the bathroom,” he climbed into bed beside her and draped his arm just under her breasts. “Would’ve been hard to explain the blood and semen.”


“Dean!” Sam snapped at him when he settled his arm over her midsection. “Is tact in your vocabulary?”


“Not right now, no,” he shook his head with a grin. “You took her virginity, Sam. Those things happen when you do that.”


“So I learned in Health class and from locker room gossip but it doesn’t mean I want to talk about it with you.”


“Whatever,” Dean rolled his eyes before he traced one finger lightly over her nipple. “You were the right choice to go first,” he said seriously as he kept his eyes focused on her puckering peak.


“Thanks,” Sam said somewhat uncomfortably before he turned his attention to what his brother was doing to their sleeping mate. “She was so responsive to everything you did to her.”


“She was to you too. Her body is learning how to react to the things that we do to her and the female body learns quickly,” he leaned forward, skimmed his tongue over her nipple before he pulled back to blow across it. “See how tight it gets from the cool air on the wet tip?”


“Yeah,” Sam leaned forward and repeated the same treatment to her neglected peak and smiled when it tightened to a point. “I can’t believe we’re doing show and tell with her when she’s passed out from exhaustion,” Sam shook his head and flushed from embarrassment.


“Yeah, now that you mention it that was awkward,” Dean furrowed his brow before he nuzzled into her side. “Add that to the list of never speaking of again,” he mumbled.


“Consider it done,” Sam snuggled up against her and closed his eyes. “Night, Dean.”


“Night, Sammy,” Dean whispered to his brother before he drifted off.




The next morning was awkward for the guys when they awoke with smiles only to find the spot Alex should’ve been in was empty. They pulled their hands back when they accidentally brushed against each other and rolled to sit on opposite sides of the bed.


“Morning, gentlemen,” Alex smiled when she emerged from the bathroom already showered and dressed for the day.


“Hey baby,” they said in unison as they rose to their feet.


“What’s on the agenda today?” Dean asked after he recovered from syncing with Sam.


“I’m afraid I don’t have time,” she said lightly as she packed her things in her bag. “I’ve got a hit that I need to check on.”


“What is it?” Sam asked as he went to his duffel to dig out some clothes. “Any idea what we’re looking at?”


“You mean what I’m looking at,” the look in her eyes stopped him cold. “We’ve hunted together but we don’t ride together, Sam. I’m still a solo act that helps out when the situation calls for it.”


“Alex, what the hell are you talking about?” Dean walked forward to question her when he saw Sam’s face fall. “After everything we went through last night, you’re okay with just riding out of here?”


“I told you that you knew the job and I wouldn’t have to explain myself when I had to walk away. You two weren’t some kinky one-night stand to lose my pesky virginity,” her watery eyes went back and forth between them. “I already fell for the both of you before this happened and I can tell you that I will not know the touch of any other man besides you but I can’t risk hunting with you,” she hung her head with a few tears streaming down her cheeks. “If we did and I cost one of you your lives, I’d die right beside you. I think you both know that feeling,” she glanced at Dean knowingly. “This is the reason why most hunters go it alone. Not because they are territorial but they can’t stand the thought of losing their partner.”


“Alex,” Sam started forward, taking her face in his hands before he kissed her hard on the mouth. “Please don’t do this,” he whispered as he leaned his forehead against hers.


“Sam, I love you already and I can’t watch you die or force you to watch me check out. I love you too much to do that,” she kissed him gently on his lips before she turned to Dean. “The other half of my heart,” she threw herself into his arms and kissed him until he gasped for breath. “I love you, Dean,” she stood up on her tiptoes and kissed his forehead before she grabbed her bag and walked out the door.





( 5 comments — Leave a comment )
Mar. 14th, 2008 07:28 pm (UTC)
“You’re both sin on two legs for one,”

Damn it! She is definitely right.

“I could never choose between you,” she looked back and forth between them. “Both of you call to a particular side of me. If I can’t have both of you I don’t want either of you,” she whispered as she lowered her eyes.

AWWWWWWWWWWWW! You totally got me with this one.
This breaks my heart. She is so right, there's no way to choose just one of them, and the fact that she's a hunter, too, fits perfect. Any other girl would never be able to understand or to handle the situation the three of them are in.

It's so surprising that they're her first, but it's also sweet. It's so awesome how they care, and oh, cute of Dean that he let's Sam be the very first. Must be pretty hard for him though.

*sighs* Wow, this is getting really hot.
I'm so in love with your Sam for being so loving and gentle, and I'm in love with your Dean, too, because he knew Sam was the better choice for her first time.

Thank you so much again for posting this.
I really adore it.

I think I need a little break to calm down before reading the next part. *grins*
Mar. 14th, 2008 07:45 pm (UTC)
Aww! You are so making me blush. What a curveball to make her a virgin, huh? Figured with all the heartache, training, bad ass cousins, and hunting she wouldn't have time to find a man. I just thought it'd be special. I am loving your responses so far.

The third part isn't as long. ;)

Oh and don't forget that I take requests, ideas, and prompts. If you see an idea for a sequel to this or have something you'd like written - let me know. I actually started this one the night after we first spoke about Pain which was Monday and finished it last night to bring with me to post. (Net is down so I'm going over to my Dad's to post. Pathetic and I'm 40)

Feed me something to write. I've got a request for 'angry sex' with Dean but of course no rape so I'm trying to think of something to there. Could even use these characters to do it (not as a sequel but a one-shot) since Alex would know how mad one can get with the job and let him get a little too aggressive??? What do you think? Other than Sam will probably walk in after and kick his ass.

Mar. 14th, 2008 08:21 pm (UTC)
Oh be warned, I have several ideas... *grins*

How funny, yesterday or the day before it occured to me (while I was reading a fic that mentioned Sam as the one who makes love and Dean as the one who fucks, well, sort of) that it would be hot to read about Dean being, well, as you said, aggressive in a way and after that there's Sam, the gentle one.

Yeah, you're right, Alex would probably like, or at least understand why Dean might get a little rough on her.

Mar. 14th, 2008 09:18 pm (UTC)
I'll take your ideas if you want to feed em to me. I think I might try to write the 'angry sex' with Dean and Alex for that person. Might be an interesting piece of kink. Maybe have Sam walk in and see some bruising or rope burns (funny how I blush about this when I talk about it yet I can write it no problem) and go off on Dean. (now I'm laughing cuz I'm picturing this in my head) Alex will have to explain that it was ok and try to get Sam to chill, maybe by saying she liked it. Haha!

Mar. 15th, 2008 01:57 am (UTC)
I think it's something one can easily imagine.
I'd really love to see Sam's reaction. (yeah, again, I'm so in love with him *chuckles*)
But how does Dean feel afterwards? Maybe he'd feel guilty? Well, he'd certainly think that he went too far on her and he'd leave Sam and Alex alone for a while because he has to calm down himself.

( 5 comments — Leave a comment )

About Me

My name is Dee and I’m stuck in Texas physically but mentally…I’m with him.


[Sam] Dean, did you pay any attention to history class?
[Dean] Yeah. Shot heard round the world. How bills become laws...
[Sam] That's not school. That's School House Rock.
[Dean] Whatever.

The Things I Love

Stargate Atlantis, Supernatural, Ronon Dex, John Sheppard, Dean Winchester, Sam Winchester, and the high-flying Jeff Hardy!

The Hotness

By: apieceofcake

By: agt_bush

By: sn_jo

By: sweetgirl7808


Powered by LiveJournal.com